Witcher 3 Father Knows Worst Quest Walkthrough And Choices

The Blood and Wine expansion for The Witcher 3 introduces players to Toussaint, a picturesque region filled with colorful vistas and intricate side quests. Among these optional adventures, the Father Knows Worst quest presents a compelling story centered on family disputes and rivalries over an inheritance. Completing this contract requires investigating a mysterious cave, surviving dangerous monster encounters, and making a pivotal moral choice.

Starting the Quest in Beauclair

To begin the Father Knows Worst quest, Geralt must visit the Gran'place notice board in Beauclair or head directly to the cave north of the Termes Palace Ruins. Outside the cave, Geralt encounters two brothers, Hugo and Hugo's siblings, arguing about their late father's legacy and a lost filter. Speaking with them reveals that their brother Hugo went missing inside while searching for the vital distillery component.

Exploring the Cave and Rescuing Hugo

Inside the cave, Geralt must navigate through dark passages filled with hazardous thermal vents and hostile creatures. Using Witcher Senses allows Geralt to follow footprints and tracks leading deeper into the cavern system. After defeating a group of aggressive Archespores, Geralt finds Hugo hiding and learns his perspective on the family feud.

Navigating the Final Confrontation and Choices

Upon escorting Hugo safely back to the cave entrance, Geralt is confronted by the other brothers and their hired mercenaries. At this critical juncture, Geralt can either encourage the brothers to reconcile or allow the confrontation to escalate into violence. Choosing peace requires specific dialogue choices that persuade the brothers to work together and run their late father's business jointly.

Rewards and Long-Term Outcomes

If Geralt successfully resolves the dispute peacefully, the brothers open a joint shop in Beauclair where players can purchase rare alchemy ingredients later in the game. Selecting the violent path results in the death of the hostile brothers, leaving Hugo alone to run the shop with fewer overall benefits. Resolving the conflict harmoniously provides both optimal story satisfaction and practical gameplay rewards.